Top 4 Security Measures Against Silver Ticket Attacks

Silver Ticket Attacks | Protecting Your Active Directory From Cyber Threats

Silver ticket attacks are a type of cyberattack that exploits weaknesses in the Kerberos authentication protocol, which is used for secure logins within Active Directory (AD). By stealing a service account’s login information, attackers can create fake access passes within AD, granting them access to specific services while remaining undetected.

These attacks pose a serious threat to organizations of all sizes. The 2022 Verizon Data Breach Investigations Report revealed that more than 80% of hacking-related breaches involved the use of stolen or guessed passwords. A successful silver ticket exploit allows attackers to move easily within a network, stay hidden over long periods, and potentially gain access to highly sensitive information.

The consequences of a compromised AD can be disastrous. From data theft and ransomware to major disruptions in operations, the aftermath of a silver ticket attack can be very costly. It’s crucial to go beyond just trying to detect these attacks and implement proactive security measures designed to lower the risk and ensure a quick recovery if an attack succeeds.

Understanding the Silver Ticket Exploit

At the heart of a silver ticket attack lies a fundamental component of Active Directory security: the Kerberos authentication protocol. In essence, Kerberos acts as a trusted third-party. It issues “tickets” that verify a user or service’s identity and determine what they can access within a network. To construct a silver ticket, an attacker needs two crucial pieces of information:
  1. Service Principal Name (SPN): This uniquely identifies a service account within Active Directory.
  2. NTLM Hash: This is a scrambled representation of the service account’s password.

Attackers often get their hands on these details through methods like password cracking or a more targeted technique called Kerberoasting. Kerberoasting specifically targets service accounts within Active Directory. It exploits the way service account passwords are stored as part of their Service Principal Name (SPN). Attackers can request these SPNs from the domain controller and then attempt to crack the encrypted password hashes offline using brute-force or dictionary-based attacks. Once they have this sensitive data, they use specialized tools to forge a Ticket-Granting Service (TGS) ticket. This fake ticket mimics legitimate Kerberos authentication data, granting the attacker access to resources associated with the compromised service account.

It’s important to distinguish silver ticket attacks from the notorious Golden Ticket attacks. While both abuse Kerberos, a Golden Ticket grants domain-wide administrative privileges. Silver tickets, on the other hand, give the attacker access limited to what the compromised service account is normally allowed.

Why Silver Ticket Attacks are So Dangerous

The true danger of silver ticket attacks lies in their ability to bypass traditional security measures and allow attackers to operate with incredible freedom within a compromised network. Here’s a breakdown of the primary reasons these attacks pose such a significant threat:
  • Stealth Mode: Because silver ticket attacks leverage seemingly valid Kerberos processes, they often fly under the radar of traditional intrusion detection systems (IDS). This makes them particularly insidious.
  • Easy Movement: With a forged silver ticket in hand, attackers can effortlessly move through the network. They can access resources and systems typically allowed for the compromised service account, making their activity difficult to distinguish from legitimate traffic.
  • The Long Game: Attackers can lurk within a compromised network for extended periods. This allows them to slowly exfiltrate sensitive data, map out the network, or prepare for larger, more damaging attacks.

Key Security Strategies to Mitigate Silver Ticket Risk

Implementing a multi-layered security approach is crucial to defend against the stealthy and persistent nature of silver ticket exploits. Here are essential areas to focus on:

1. Robust Service Account Management

  • Strong Password Policies: Require highly complex passwords for service accounts, exceeding the usual requirements for standard user accounts. Enforce minimum length (15+ characters), a diverse mix of characters (upper case, lower case, numbers, symbols), and disallow reuse of previous passwords. Implement an automated password rotation schedule (ideally every 90 days or less) to counter offline cracking attempts.
  • Privileged Access Management (PAM): Invest in a PAM solution specifically designed for securing service account credentials. These solutions offer a centralized, encrypted vault for storing account passwords, ensuring only authorized administrators can access them. PAM tools automate password rotations according to your policies, track access attempts, and provide detailed audit trails of all activity around high-risk service accounts.
  • Principle of Least Privilege: Audit all existing service accounts and remove any permissions that are not essential for their specific function. Regularly review permissions and adjust as needed. The goal is to limit the attack surface as much as possible, ensuring that even if a service account credential is stolen, the attacker can’t leverage it for widespread damage.

2. Securing the Kerberos Delegation Process

  • Understanding Delegation: Study how Kerberos delegation works within your environment and which service accounts rely on it. Pay close attention to the various delegation types (unconstrained, constrained, resource-based constrained). Having a clear understanding is essential for informed security decisions.
  • Disable Unconstrained Delegation: Strive to eliminate the use of unconstrained delegation. It grants broad permissions for accounts to represent users across any service – highly attractive to attackers. If possible, completely disable this legacy setting in your AD environment.
  • Constrained Delegation: If disabling unconstrained delegation proves impossible, transition to constrained delegation. With this approach, you precisely define which services a service account is allowed to delegate to. This limits an attacker’s ability to move laterally, even if they compromise a service account with delegation rights.

3. Enforcing Network Segmentation and Least Privilege

  • Network Zoning: Design your network with the assumption that a breach will occur. By segmenting your network into smaller, isolated zones (through VLANs, firewalls, or software-defined networking), you limit the scope of an attacker’s reach. Even with a compromised service account, their access will be primarily contained within the zone where the compromise occurred. This buys you invaluable time to detect and respond.
  • Least Privilege Across the Board: Implement the principle of least privilege for every user, service account, and device in your environment. Regularly review and revoke unnecessary permissions. Use tools like Group Policy Objects (GPOs) in Active Directory to help manage permissions efficiently on a large scale. The underlying goal is to reduce the attack surface, ensuring that no account possesses more access than what is absolutely necessary.

4. Advanced Monitoring and Detection

  • SIEM Tools: A Security Information and Event Management solution is crucial for aggregating, normalizing, and correlating logs from Active Directory, firewalls, servers, and other critical systems. Invest time into developing custom rules that specifically look for abnormal signs related to silver ticket activity, such as access attempts outside typical service account usage patterns.
  • Focus on Behavior: Pay close attention to unusual patterns in service account activity – authentications outside normal hours, unexpected access requests, or attempts to access highly sensitive resources that don’t align with that account’s normal function. Behavioral analysis can help flag potential silver ticket activity.

Beyond Detection: Active Directory Resilience

While the preventative strategies we’ve outlined are crucial for minimizing the risk of silver ticket attacks, it’s essential to be prepared for the possibility of a breach. These attacks can be difficult to detect, meaning even organizations with robust security may eventually find themselves facing a compromised Active Directory. This is where comprehensive recovery capabilities come into play.

Traditional backups often fall short when dealing with a deeply compromised AD. System state backups might replicate corrupted data or malicious changes made by attackers. This could lead to a restoration that leaves your AD in a vulnerable, or even entirely unusable state.

Specialized forest recovery solutions, like Cayosoft Guardian, are crucial for quick and reliable restoration of AD integrity after an attack. These solutions go beyond traditional backup methods. They offer:

  • Granular Restoration: The ability to restore individual AD objects (users, groups, computer accounts), attributes, or even specific attribute values. This ensures you can surgically repair damage without rolling back your entire AD to a potentially vulnerable point in time.
  • Change Tracking and Historical Comparisons: Advanced forest recovery allows tracking of all changes made in AD in detail. This visibility allows companies to compare the current state of AD with past points in time to pinpoint the scope and impact of an attack accurately.
  • Protection of Backup Data: Cayosoft Guardian safeguards AD backup repositories by enforcing strict access controls and shielding backup data from unauthorized changes or tampering. This guarantees that you always have a trustworthy recovery point to rely on in the case of potential compromise.

Protecting Your Active Directory from Silver Ticket Attacks

Silver ticket attacks remain a severe threat for any organization reliant on Active Directory. Take decisive measures to protect your AD environment and implement the robust security strategies outlined in this blog. However, understand that even the best defenses can sometimes be breached. Prepare for this reality by investing in a comprehensive forest recovery solution like Cayosoft Guardian. Gain the power to pinpoint malicious changes, restore individual AD elements with precision, and rapidly bring your Active Directory back to a secure, healthy state.


Organizations can detect if a silver ticket attack has already occurred by closely monitoring for anomalies in their Active Directory environments, such as irregularities in service account activities, unexpected access patterns, or authentication requests that do not align with normal user behavior. Utilizing advanced Security Information and Event Management (SIEM) tools that can aggregate and analyze logs from various sources within the network can also help identify suspicious activities indicative of a silver ticket attack. Additionally, implementing anomaly detection systems that specifically look for deviations in typical authentication processes can aid in early detection.
Upon discovering a silver ticket attack, the initial steps an organization should take include isolating the affected systems to prevent further unauthorized access or lateral movement by the attacker. This involves revoking the compromised service account’s credentials, assessing the scope of the attack to understand which parts of the network are impacted, and conducting a thorough investigation to determine how the attack was carried out. Engaging a cyber incident response team to contain the attack, get rid of the attacker’s presence, and recover any affected systems is critical. After securing the network, conducting a detailed analysis to identify the attack’s entry point and implementing stronger security measures to prevent future incidents is essential.
Silver ticket attacks can significantly impact cloud-based resources or services that are integrated with Active Directory, as attackers may gain unauthorized access to cloud services by exploiting the compromised AD credentials. This unauthorized access can lead to data breaches, unauthorized data access, and potentially taking control of cloud-based resources. It underscores the importance of securing both on-premises and cloud environments against such attacks by ensuring consistent security policies and measures are applied across all platforms.
Implementing multi-factor authentication (MFA) can indeed reduce the risk of silver ticket attacks by adding an additional layer of security beyond just the knowledge of passwords or hashes. MFA requires users to provide two or more verification factors to gain access to a resource, such as a password combined with a temporary code sent to a mobile device. This makes it much harder for attackers to gain unauthorized access using stolen credentials alone, as they would also need to compromise the additional authentication factor.
Organizations should conduct security audits regularly to effectively minimize the risk of silver ticket attacks. The frequency of these audits can vary depending on the organization’s size, complexity of the IT environment, and the sensitivity of the data it handles. However, it is generally recommended to perform security audits at least annually or whenever significant changes are made to the IT infrastructure. Regular audits help identify vulnerabilities, assess the effectiveness of current security measures, and ensure that security policies are being followed, allowing organizations to address potential security gaps before they can be exploited by attackers.

See Cayosoft Guardian In Action

Schedule a demo to learn more about how Cayosoft’s solutions can improve your AD management and secure it from cyber threats.

Check out these relevant resources.

New Survey Finds...

Active Directory forest recovery not taken serious enough. See what else your peers had to say.